Would a Second Payment Counter Shorten the Lunch Queue?
By the time you reach the front of the lunch queue at the college festival, the cashier is taking payments quickly. The volunteer takes your payment and hands you ticket 32. Across the stall, the packing team is still calling numbers from the teens.
Keep a copy of your work. Responses save only in this browser on this device. They are not submitted or synced. Export before changing devices or clearing browser data. Private browsing may not retain your work.
Your work stays in this browser.
Where is everyone waiting?
The manager can see the line at the payment counter from outside the stall. From inside, you can also see the people holding paid tickets. Before you move anyone, follow one order through the whole stall.
From payment to collection
Customers choose a wrap or a bowl when they pay. The cashier sends the ticket to packing, where volunteers either pack the meal or take a matching one from the shelf. At collection, a volunteer checks the ticket and hands over lunch. Everyone stays in arrival order, including customers whose meals are ready in advance.
Operations management looks at how people and materials move through a process. Here the manager could report a record number of payments while customers are still waiting for lunch. In a management course, you might map that process, time each station and change one part at a time to see whether customers actually benefit.
Your brief from the manager
Design a shift that hands over at least 23 meals by the end of minute four and leaves at most two advance-packed meals unused once everyone has eaten. Meet both targets on two different breaks. Your final note should tell the next shift where to put its spare volunteer, how many meals to have ready and what to watch once orders start coming in.
The case runs in simulated minutes. You can pause, compare results and return later. All the figures and rules you need are in the workbook.
Would another cashier help ticket 32?
Start with the original team and an empty shelf. Replay the same customers with an extra cashier, then with an extra packer. Use the arrows to see what happens before and after minute four.
What one minute means
The original team can take six payments, pack four fresh meals and hand over eight lunches per minute. One spare volunteer can staff a second payment counter (+6 payments), join packing (+4 fresh meals) or join collection (+8 handovers). The other stations keep their original teams.
At the start of minutes one to four, 10, 10, 8 and 4 customers arrive respectively. No one else joins. In each minute customers pay first, then packing, then collection. A ticket can move through all three in that minute. A customer arriving at the start of minute two and collecting at the end of minute three has waited two minutes.
Replay the first lunch rush
Your staffing comparisons at minute four
Use a queue count and a customer outcome to explain why the second payment counter looks persuasive from the front of the stall.
What should be ready when the shutters open?
The kitchen offers a shelf beside packing. A meal prepared before the break takes no fresh packing slot when a matching ticket comes up, but a bowl cannot fill an order for a wrap.
The kitchen’s order book
Yesterday’s early break sold 20 wraps and 12 bowls. The later break sold 12 wraps and 20 bowls. In the first replay today, customers ordered 26 wraps and six bowls. You do not yet have the second rush’s orders.
You can prepare up to eight meals in any mix before opening. During service, packing uses a matching prepared meal first and otherwise packs to order. Prepared meals count towards the service target only at handover. An unused meal still occupies its shelf space when service ends.
Try a shift plan
Write down which queue you expect to shorten and what could go wrong if the next customers order differently.
Would you run the next shift the same way?
The manager needs instructions she can give the volunteers before they open. Use the two breaks to decide which parts of your original plan you can rely on.
File a plan on the previous page to open the second rush.
What the second break changed
The same 32 customers arrive at the same times, but this time four order wraps and 28 order bowls. Replay your filed plan first. If you revise the staffing or the batch, run the revised plan on both breaks before you hand it over.
Try a shift plan
Does this shift meet the brief?
Compare your filed plan with your final decision. Use results from both breaks. If you kept the plan, identify the risk you checked.
Tell the manager where to place the volunteer, how many wraps and bowls to prepare, when to stop advance packing, and what to measure before changing the plan mid-service.
Which would you want to investigate next: measuring the queue on site, forecasting tomorrow’s orders or organising the people on shift? Explain what prompted your interest.