A garden committee has one morning watering slot and a fixed equipment budget. Decide which system deserves a site trial, then use the measurements to advise the committee.
Free accessCalculator usefulDesign and testing
Keep a copy of your work. Responses save only in this browser on this device. They are not submitted or synced. Export before changing devices or clearing browser data. Private browsing may not retain your work.
Your work stays in this browser.
The East Wall garden
Every morning a volunteer has 45 minutes to water twelve beds. The committee wants to know what to buy and what evidence to ask for before spending its money.
What engineers study
Engineering brings mathematics, physical science and design together to make things work under constraints. Civil engineers might plan how water moves across a site, mechanical engineers examine how a pump performs, and electrical engineers consider the energy it draws. Here you will work at the point where those decisions meet.
At university, a fluid mechanics calculation might predict a flow rate. A laboratory class asks you to measure it. In a design studio, you have to explain a discrepancy and decide what it changes for the people using the system. You will do a small version of each in this case.
Your commission
Prepare a purchasing note a volunteer committee can act on. You will mark out a route, compare suppliers, lay out the hose on a site plan, and specify a trial. The field log opens after you file your first proposal. Keep a calculator handy. Ratios, multiplication and division are all you need. The figures are fictional and all the evidence is here.
Work in two sittings if you prefer. A natural stopping point is the saved proposal. At the end, export your work to keep both your original design and your final advice.
Read the site as an engineer
The volunteer’s account and the site plan describe different parts of the same problem.
From the garden coordinator
“We start with 520 litres of usable rainwater in the tank. Each of our twelve beds needs 40 litres at its inlet every morning. We water one bed at a time. The footpath is the only entrance and must stay clear. Our daily pump allowance is 95 watt-hours. The equipment budget is ₹10,000. Among systems that meet every limit, buy the least expensive.”
Survey sketch · plan view
The tank feeds the pump beside it. From the pump, the direct route to the bed rail measures 20 m and crosses the paved public footpath. The boundary route follows the two wall lengths shown on the plan. The fixed rail and valves are already installed. Each offer includes 32 m of hose, fittings and a meter.
The 45-minute limit applies to pumping time. Allow zero switching time and zero leakage in this model. Use the total litres delivered at the beds. Energy and price limits are inclusive. A design must pass all limits.
Identify one requirement a faster pump cannot solve. Explain how a volunteer could check that every bed received its share even if the total volume was correct.
Compare three supplier offers
Use the suppliers’ figures to decide what deserves a field trial.
What the quotes cover
Quoted kit prices and short-hose bench measurements
Kit
Flow (L/min)
Input power (W)
Full kit (₹)
Alder
12
120
7,700
Birch
16
165
9,400
Cedar
24
300
8,900
Alder · ₹7,700
Full kit price. Bench flow 12 L/min at 120 W.
Birch · ₹9,400
Full kit price. Bench flow 16 L/min at 165 W.
Cedar · ₹8,900
Full kit price. Bench flow 24 L/min at 300 W.
Treat quoted power as constant while running. Bench flow was measured with a short, level hose. It is a provisional estimate for the longer garden route. All kits cover the permitted route and use the same existing tank and bed rail.
Read the units
Flow is volume delivered per minute. Running time in minutes = required litres ÷ flow. Energy in watt-hours = input watts × running minutes ÷ 60. Price is paid once. Energy is consumed on every run.
For example, delivering 150 L at 10 L/min takes 15 minutes. A 100 W pump operating for those 15 minutes consumes 25 Wh. A powerful pump can finish quickly and still use more energy over the run.
Enter exact numbers without units. Compare each result with the coordinator’s limits.
Put a design forward
Lay out the route and choose the equipment. Leave instructions a volunteer could use to run your trial tomorrow.
The purchasing conversation
The treasurer favours the lowest purchase price. A volunteer favours a quicker finish because the gate closes on time. Use the coordinator’s buying rule to nominate a kit for a trial. Record how much time the quicker feasible kit would save and what it would cost to gain that time.
Lay out the hose
The tank already feeds the pump beside it. Your job is to take one hose from the pump to the rail that waters the beds. People enter through the bottom gate and walk along the paved footpath. They must be able to use it while the pump runs.
Grey paving marks the public footpath. The green line shows your chosen hose. Select the other route to compare.
The rail supplies one bed at a time. Losses along the route are greatest at the far end. Choose a test point and its marker will appear on your plan.
Choose a kit for the trial
Use your supplier comparison and the committee’s buying rule. This is the recommendation you will revisit after the field trial.
Name one assumption in the quote and a field result that would make you reconsider.
Specify the route, where to collect water, what to measure and in which units. Explain one condition to hold constant, why to repeat the test, and what result would send your design back for revision.
What happened on the garden route?
Use the field team’s measurements to decide which parts of your proposal survive.
File your sketch, selection and test instructions on the previous page to open the field log.
Your filed service plan and trial proposal
Field notebook
The team used loan kits on the same wall route and tested at the most distant outlet, which gives the lowest flow. Each entry is litres collected in exactly two minutes after flow stabilised. Other outlets can be regulated to the same delivery rate. The engineer controlled tank level, outlet setting and supply. Input power during testing matched each quoted value.
Two-minute collections at the bed inlet
Configuration
Run 1 (L)
Run 2 (L)
Run 3 (L)
Alder · original hose
17
16
18
Birch · original hose
31
32
30
Alder · wider hose
25
24
26
The team also borrowed a compatible wider hose. It follows the same route and adds ₹1,100 to Alder’s complete price. For this decision, use the lowest measured flow from the three runs as the planning rate. Recalculate the time and energy for 480 L. Cedar has no field measurements and already exceeds the energy limit on its quote.
Which measurement changed your confidence? Distinguish the observed change in flow from a possible physical explanation. A longer or narrower hose can offer more resistance to flow. Name one additional measurement you would request before attributing the entire change to hose resistance.
Write the purchasing note
The committee needs a decision today and a practical acceptance test before it signs off.
In two short paragraphs, recommend the exact kit and hose. Quantify its margins against time, energy and budget. Compare the next best option. Set out what the volunteer should measure on the first full run and what result would make you pause the purchase. Explain how a 35-minute slot would change your advice.
Review your note
Could the treasurer identify exactly what to order? Could a volunteer tell when to stop watering a bed? Can both see where measurement replaced an assumption? Your calculations receive automatic feedback. Use these questions to review the quality of your advice.
Recall a point where calculation, drawing, testing or explaining a compromise changed your thinking. Which part would you choose to investigate in a college lab, and why?
A reading to take further
Find the point in your own work where test evidence sent you back to a design choice. Compare that moment with the return arrow in the NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory design diagram.